Where to Eat the Freshest Seafood in Key Largo

Key Largo is a seafood lover's paradise, and staying at Ocean Pointe Suites puts you just minutes from some of the freshest, most flavorful catches in the Florida Keys. Whether you're craving grilled mahi, chilled stone crab claws, or an elevated lobster roll with waterfront views, the local restaurants deliver quality and variety. Many of these spots source directly from local fishermen daily, offering a true taste of the ocean. Below are five standout seafood destinations, each within easy reach of your suite and perfect for lunch, dinner, or a laid-back afternoon bite.

1. The Fish House Restaurant & Seafood Market

Distance from Ocean Pointe ~ approx. 10 miles
The Fish House procures only whole fish from local commercial fishermen and fillets each catch on-site to ensure peak freshness. Their Matecumbe‑style Snapper is pan‑seared with a citrus‑butter sauce, showcasing their local catch. Stone Crab Claws (in season) arrive daily from nearby trappers and are served chilled to highlight their natural sweetness. If you bring your own catch, they'll cook it for you adding a hands‑on, customized dining experience.

2. Key Largo Fisheries Backyard Café

Distance from Ocean Pointe ~ 5.9 miles
This waterfront café sits right where local fishermen dock, processing and serving their catch daily. Try the Grilled Mahi Tacos, featuring fresh mahi wrapped in warm tortillas with slaw and house salsa. The Florida Lobster Roll layers sweet lobster meat in a buttery roll, embodying island simplicity. With over 100 menu items, this spot offers a casual atmosphere and unmatched freshness.

3. Sol by the Sea

Distance from Ocean Pointe ~ approx. 7 miles
An elegant open‑air restaurant on the waterfront, it blends island flavors with Keys‑fresh fish. The Lobster Roll here is elevated with generous lobster chunks tucked into a light brioche roll. Equally impressive is the Crispy Whole Thai Snapper, crispy‑skinned and glazed with sweet‑spicy Thai sauce. The setting makes it ideal for a relaxed yet sophisticated meal.

4. Calusa

Distance from Ocean Pointe ~ approx. 6 miles
Calusa puts a focus on sustainability through creative presentations . Their Keys Pink Shrimp Cocktail is blackened, chilled, and served with a coconut‑mustard aioli that adds tropical flair. The Bang Bang Calamari pairs tender calamari with shishito peppers and fennel in a bright, spicy sauce. It's a balance of upscale plating and genuine Keys flavors.

5. Hobo's Café

Distance from Ocean Pointe ~ approx. 6 miles
A family-friendly, casual café that consistently offers local fish, tuna, and lobster in a laid-back atmosphere . The Blackened Mahi Mahi comes coated in Cajun spices, seared to a crisp, and served with side options like rice or fresh veggies. Though not seafood, their Key Lime Pie in a Jar provides the perfect tangy‑sweet finish to your meal. Expect unpretentious service and hearty portions.

Why These Restaurants Shine

All five focus on locally caught seafood, delivering unmatched freshness. You'll find a range of styles, from pan‑seared and blackened to Thai‑inspired crunch and coastal comfort food. Each delivers a unique atmosphere, whether you're looking for elegant waterfront dining or relaxed, family‑geared spots. And best of all, none are more than a 10‑mile (about 20‑minute) drive from Ocean Pointe Suites, so you can enjoy a seafood route without a long commute.

Ready to Make It a Getaway?

After sampling these exceptional seafood destinations, return to comfort and convenience at Ocean Pointe Suites. With spacious ocean‑front suites, private beach access, a junior‑Olympic pool and full kitchens, it's the perfect base for your Key Largo culinary adventure. Book now and make fresh‑seafood days and relaxing evenings part of your stay.