The Ultimate Foodie’s Guide to Treasure Island

Treasure Island, Florida, may be best known for its stunning Gulf Coast beaches, but it’s also home to a vibrant culinary scene that blends fresh seafood, casual coastal dining, and creative flavors. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or simply looking for memorable meals during your stay, these five spots showcase the best of Treasure Island’s dining culture.

 

Middle Grounds Grill

A Treasure Island staple, Middle Grounds Grill is the go-to for upscale seafood and steak. Known for dishes like mango nut–crusted grouper, twin lobster tails, and coconut almond shrimp, this restaurant combines fine dining with a relaxed coastal atmosphere. Their extensive wine list and signature desserts, such as the Key Lime Tower, make it a must-visit for a special night out.

 

Caddy’s Treasure Island

For a true beachfront experience, Caddy’s Treasure Island lets you dine with your toes in the sand. Famous for its grouper sandwiches, fish tacos, and lively atmosphere, Caddy’s offers live music most afternoons and a family-friendly vibe during the day. As the sun sets, it transforms into a vibrant spot for cocktails and casual dining right on the Gulf.

 

The Pearl Restaurant

If you’re craving Mediterranean-inspired cuisine, The Pearl Restaurant delivers with dishes like lamb shank, seafood paella, and fresh pasta. The intimate setting makes it an ideal choice for couples or small groups seeking a refined dining experience. The Pearl is celebrated for its attentive service and creative menu that blends European flavors with Florida freshness.

 

The Candy Kitchen

No foodie guide is complete without dessert, and The Candy Kitchen is a Treasure Island institution. This retro-style shop offers homemade fudge, saltwater taffy, and hand-dipped chocolates, alongside ice cream and Italian ice. It’s a whimsical stop that delights both kids and adults, perfect for satisfying a sweet tooth after a day at the beach.

 

Ka’Tiki Bar

For a laid-back local vibe, Ka’Tiki Bar is a casual spot known for its burgers, onion rings, and friendly atmosphere. It’s a favorite among locals and visitors alike, offering live music and a relaxed setting that captures the essence of Treasure Island’s beach culture. It’s the perfect place to unwind with comfort food and a cold drink after exploring the island.

 

Where to Stay: Oceana Beachfront Suites

After indulging in Treasure Island’s diverse dining scene, you’ll want a comfortable and stylish place to relax. Oceana Beachfront Suites offers spacious accommodations, modern amenities, and unbeatable Gulf views. With its prime location, you’ll be just steps away from many of the island’s best restaurants, making it the perfect home base for your foodie adventure.

Book your stay at Oceana Beachfront Suites today and savor the ultimate Treasure Island experience—both on the plate and by the shore.