Best Seafood Restaurants in Treasure Island

Treasure Island, Florida, is a paradise for seafood lovers. With its Gulf Coast location, the island offers fresh catches prepared in a variety of styles, from casual beachside bites to upscale dining experiences. Here are some of the best seafood restaurants to explore during your visit.

 

Middle Grounds Grill

A local favorite, Middle Grounds Grill is known for its upscale yet welcoming atmosphere. The menu features standout dishes, including mango–nut–crusted grouper, coconut-almond shrimp, and grilled honey-ginger salmon. With an extensive wine list and decadent desserts, this is the perfect spot for a refined evening out.

 

Caddy’s Treasure Island

For a true beachfront dining experience, Caddy’s Treasure Island lets you enjoy fresh seafood with your toes in the sand. Their grouper sandwiches, fish tacos, and peel-and-eat shrimp are staples, and live music adds to the lively atmosphere. It’s a great place to soak in the Gulf views while savoring casual coastal fare.

 

The Pearl Restaurant

If you’re looking for Mediterranean-inspired flavors, The Pearl Restaurant offers a unique take on seafood. Dishes such as seafood paella, mussels in a white wine sauce, and fresh pasta highlight the menu. The intimate setting makes it ideal for couples or small groups seeking a more elevated dining experience.

 

Sloppy Joe’s on the Beach

A Treasure Island institution, Sloppy Joe’s on the Beach combines casual dining with unbeatable views. Their menu includes fresh grouper, mahi-mahi, and shrimp prepared in a variety of ways. With a laid-back vibe and beachfront location, it’s a great spot for families and groups to enjoy hearty seafood dishes.

 

Shrimpys Waterfront

Located just over the bridge near Treasure Island, Shrimpys Waterfront is worth the short trip. Known for its Cajun and Creole-inspired seafood, the restaurant serves dishes such as blackened grouper, crawfish étouffée, and shrimp po’boys. The waterfront setting adds to the charm, making it a memorable dining experience.

 

End Your Day in Comfort at Crystal Palms

After indulging in Treasure Island’s incredible seafood scene, you’ll want a place to relax and recharge. Crystal Palms Beach Resort offers spacious suites, modern amenities, and stunning Gulf views, making it the perfect retreat after a day of dining and exploring.

Book your stay at Crystal Palms Beach Resort today and pair Treasure Island’s best seafood with the comfort of a beachfront getaway.